Underemployed Under the Radar on the North Shore

Only partially tracked in government statistics, underemployment common in highly educated populations like Glenview's

Less than a year ago, Tim Hendricks was a vice president and stock trader 21 years into a career at Merrill Lynch in downtown Chicago. These days Hendricks is selling refrigerators and air conditioners at – and happy to have the job.

He’s one of the countless underemployed workers created by the current recession – countless as in no one is keeping track of them.

The U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics tracks one segment of the underemployed: those who are working part time but would rather be working full-time.


Involuntary part-timers

In addition to the 9.3 percent unemployed the U.S. reported in the second quarter, another 5.6 percent are what the bureau’s alternative labor statistics report calls “part time for economic reasons.”

In Illinois the unemployment rate was 9.4 percent with another 6.1 percent involuntarily working part time hours - which generally means no benefits like health insurance and sick leave.

Like the the other north Chicago suburbs, Glenview's unemployment rate is substantially lower because its workforce tends to be more highly educated and highly skilled. But for those same reasons, it is especially susceptible to the other type of underemployment.

Government statistics don’t keep count of people who, like Hendricks, are working full-time jobs below their skill and experience levels. Sometimes called “mal-employment” by economists, this type of underemployment is hard to gauge without surveys because these workers aren’t applying for government benefits.

“This question has been around a while but no one’s measuring it,” said Paul LaPorte, who works in the BLS office of economic analysis and information in Chicago.

“That’s the true definition of underemployment,” LaPorte said, “underutilizing your skills; you have qualifications yet somehow through no fault of your own you got stuck doing this other job.”

Funding your job search

Jan Leahy sees both types of underemployment every day as director of the Career Resource Center in Lake Forest, a non-profit that primarily helps professionals who are looking for work.

In this tough economy, it’s “not uncommon” to see people with graduate degrees or decades of professional experience taking retail sales or other service jobs to bring in some income while they continue a job search, Leahy said.

Job seekers who have put a lot of effort into sending out resumes and making connections have to decide whether to accept lesser offers in their fields: shorter term assignments or contract work, Leahy said.

“It’s a difficult choice because it does take them out of the market and there can be a loss of momentum with their job search,” she said.

Short-term jobs can open doors

Taking a contract job was the right decision for Pam Siudyla of Highland Park, who just completed a 10-month assignment in the purchasing department of Rust-Oleum in Vernon Hills that was initially supposed to last three months. Siudyla said she had been unemployed nearly 6 months and took the job because she “needed to do something.” Now she's on the job hunt again. 

While she was at Rust-Oleum, she learned how to use the business management software SAP and made some valuable connections.

“It worked out well because I was able to update my computer skills, earn a little money and keep my experience current,” Siudyla said.

Another “underemployed” worker with a unique perspective on the job market is Pat McGarrigle of Lake Forest, who has 30 years experience with hiring and firing other people in human resources.

He’s now working three days per week as HR director for the 200 employees at a Joliet company that recycles cooking oil into animal feed and biodiesel. The 62-year-old spends the rest of his time looking for a full-time job where he can finish out his career.

He has been doing shorter-term human resources gigs since last June, when the Des Plaines packaging company where he had been HR director nearly 10 years was bought out by a rival and he was let go.

Like Siudyla, he said taking contract work has been good experience, teaching him a few new tricks and allowing him to share his own wealth of knowledge.

“I like knowing I may be able to help the company improve their processes and to have that be appreciated,” he said.

“It makes you feel good at a time when you really need a ego boost.”

Working three days per week also provides some “respite and reprieve” from the job search grind, McGarrigle said.

“It can get rather frustrating doing that day in and day out,” he said.

Unexpected rewards

Taking jobs that don’t necessarily use all of your skill set can be extremely rewarding, said Leahy, the Career Resources Center director.

She recalled one professional worker who decided to get a retail job while he was looking for career employment and, since he was an avid fisherman, applied at a Bass Pro Shop and ended up loving the job.

Likewise, Hendricks said he wasn’t sure what to expect going from selling an abstract idea like stocks to selling refrigerators and washers and dryers at Abt. 

Now he loves it – and the Glenview family-owned business where he works, its “Fortune 500” level benefits, onsite fitness center and his fellow employees.

“I’m not going anywhere,” he said. “This is my career now.”

Want to receive news and participate in the conversation? "Like" Glenview Patch on Facebook!

Tim Froehlig August 02, 2011 at 07:10 PM
This is an excellent story that has gone unreported by the mainstream media for far too long. Thanks Carrie and Joanna for posting it.
Pam Siudyla August 04, 2011 at 09:21 PM
Hi Carrie, Great story but it needs a slight correction. I didn't "need something to do". I "needed to do something". Had to learn something to enhance my skills and pay the mortgage. Pam Siudyla
Joanna Schneider August 05, 2011 at 03:14 AM
Thanks for letting us know about the correction, Pam. I've made a change in the article. Again, thanks for sharing your story with Patch!


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »