Op-Ed: 9/11 Reflections by a Pakistani-American Muslim

Glenview resident K. Rizwan Kadir is the President of Pakistan Club at the University of Chicago’s Booth School of Business and serves on the board of several Islamic organizations in the U.S.

As a Chicagoan, I’m very proud of the Willis (formerly Sears) Tower and the John Hancock center. Not only do these buildings aptly epitomize the City of Broad Shoulders, the fact they were designed by a Pakistani-American Muslim adds another dimension of pride for me. Since 9/11, American Muslims have identified with the US and differentiated from the violent extremist mindset which has permeated parts of the Muslim world since the Soviet-Afghan war. In my mind, there is no better symbol of this differentiation than the former Sears Tower – we are the kind of Muslims who build things to reflect our high aspirations as a civilized nation, and are not the ones who want to smash planes into such buildings.

The events of 9/11 were perpetrated by misguided Muslims whose belief in a twisted version of Islam is anathema to most Muslims, both in the West and in the rest of the Muslim world. Committing suicide is a major sin in Islam, and the only act one cannot ask for forgiveness if carried out successfully. As has been the tradition in Islamic cultures for centuries, no funeral rites were held for the 19 hijackers anywhere in the Muslim world. For Muslims, an act of suicide is deemed taking away the greatest gift God bestows upon us.

About 60 Muslims died in the Twin Towers, which in a numerical coincidence, reflects the percentage of Muslims in the US. In other words, we American Muslims felt the same, but we carried – and continue to carry – other burdens, namely, distinguishing Islam from any virulent ideologies, standing up for our civic rights in the US, correcting misinformation about us in the media, and also denouncing anti-Americanism in the Muslim world.

It seems fitting that in this 10th year of 9/11, the main perpetrator, Osama bin Laden, was captured and killed. A collective sigh of relief was echoed throughout the Muslim world and amongst the American Muslims. In a larger context, it was a non-event, as only a chapter has been closed; the wider war on terrorism and Islam’s battle against his twisted ideology continue.

Since 9/11, in a globalized cobweb of strategic and tactical relationships, the US and Pakistani nation destinies are even more intertwined now. Specifically, 9/11 didn’t end in a field in Pennsylvania (that’s’ where the last plane on 9/11 went down); the battleground moved to Pakistan, where since 9/11, over 30,000 innocent have died as a result of suicide bombings. Another 3,000 soldiers – from rank and file to general levels – have died fighting the same people and ideology which perpetrated 9/11s’ tragic events.

It’s really ironic that the world’s largest Muslim army – the Pakistani army – is fighting a war on its soil. No wonder, then, that the attacks by the Taliban since bin Laden’s death have been directed at Pakistan’s armed forces. Almost all of the high-value terrorists have been captured in Pakistan, who slipped out of Afghanistan after the war started there in 2002. Just this week, a major Al-Qaeda operative was captured, once again with collaboration between the CIA and the Pakistani intelligence agencies, only to have the head of paramilitary police in that town die in a suicide bombing at his house.

Why do they hate us?

People throughout the world love America and Americans – that’s why they keep coming to these shores as emigrants and international students. Regrettably, the same can’t be said of the US foreign policies, which often cater more to special interests than our national security concerns. Globally, our support of corrupt regimes does not buy us any political currency or legitimacy. More significantly, it’s against this backdrop that bin Ladens of world are seen by the disenfranchised masses as a David who stand up against the Goliathan West.

Moreover, looking the other way to the human right abuses in Israel and the Indian-occupied Kashmir provide a tremendous amount of fodder to the terrorists’ mantra of violent reactions. Both of these perennially tinderbox of issues – each over 60 years old now – are the raison d’être for much of the extremism in the Muslim world. Even those not directly connected to these issues use them to advance their political agendas.

Lessons of the Last Decade:

American Muslims grew up in a hurry, as we felt the double whammy of a national tragedy which was conducted in the name of our faith. We came out of our comfort zones, and rallied hard against the extremist mindset. At the same time, an average American learned more about Islamic than we ever would have under normal circumstances.

Islamophobia became a phenomenon during the last decade, and every conversation about Muslims in America seemed to be upper- and lower-bounded by the terrorism narrative. It’s as if an admissions price had been placed on us, that is, before we are allowed to sit at the proverbial civilized nations’ table, we are expected to denounce this and distance ourselves from that. Hopefully, after 10 years of concerted rhetoric, substantiated by actions, we – as a nation – move beyond that narrative. The American Muslims used to be defined by who we are not; now, we hope to be defined by who we are – citizens who add value to the society.

In the last 10 years, we have encountered the complex challenge of radicalism, felt compelled to revisit some of our foreign policies, realized that Judeo-Christian traditions in this country have a global partner in Islam, and saw the best and worst this nation of ours has to offer. How can we forget Colin Powell’s contemplation at a picture of a American Muslim mother hugging her fallen US soldier son’s gravestone and wondering so what if Obama were a Muslim? Worst: A Florida pastor – seeking publicity – decided to burn the Quran, but again, the best of our society emerged when someone no less than General Petraeus asked him to back down. Our non-Muslim friends in the UK started Read the Quran Day on Facebook in reaction. Last year, Mayor Bloomberg rightly pointed out that incessant arguments over the so-called Ground Zero mosque would die down after the elections, which it did.


I have two cousins in the US Marines, both of whom have done two combat tours of Iraq. Their father, a retired major from the Pakistan Army, fought two wars for Pakistan. But after immigrating to the US, he made sure that both of his sons serve the armed forces in his adopted new country.

A recent expose by the Center for American Progress revealed that propaganda money to the tune of $42 million was spent to disseminate misinformation to the churches. American Muslims don’t have any financial resources to counter that, but we have a trust fund with the American society which, in times of confusion, relies on its panache for basic decency and truthfulness. For example, two minor examples from local churches re-affirm that faith: In Northbrook, the day after 9/11, a group of parishioners offered to form a chain of hands outside a newly-built Islamic school – for as long as the need be. In Morton Grove, leaders from the local St. Martha church walked over to the MCC School on 9/11/2001 to see if everything was ok. A couple of years later when someone threw a stone at the mosque’s window, St. Martha collected donations to pay for the repair. Such bits of Americana cannot be forgotten, and in a profound way, affirm my belief that the US has always – always – ended up on the right side of history.

Want to receive local news and participate in the conversation? "Like" us on Facebook!

Bob September 11, 2011 at 08:44 PM
Bringing kasmir and israel in this discussion shows your hypocrisy. Does your father realize if he made a grave mistake separating and attacking a largest non-violent country in the history of mankind? you think good people are scared of terrorism and shall continue to give up to your cowardly act. It is matter of time that Pakistan will learn and shall soon behave like a good kid in the block. Oh..yeah..please stop misusing american money like your another pakistani in disguise was doing it captured by FBI.
kj September 11, 2011 at 09:02 PM
My favorite quote: "All that is needed for evil to prevail is for good men (and women) to do nothing"
Dom Tar September 11, 2011 at 10:40 PM
Beatrice, the author is not the enemy. Yet you are treating him like one. Do you want a friend or an enemy ? That is the question we all need to answer for ourselves.
Janet P September 12, 2011 at 03:42 AM
I can tell that the author is bitter toward America by his tone. It's ashame. He could have spent the whole article telling us how we could make America better, or condemning what happened himself. It also shows that for as much as he points out America's many flaws, that he has a one-sided view of the prevailing attitude of what went on fter that awful day as well. The Muslim religion has been fighting wars for thousands of years, with no resolution. Just as Christians have across the world. Perhaps the message here is you and othe should put your hateful (yes, your words are filled with veiled hate, sir) feelings aside and simply start treating each other with respect and kindness and stop believing your thoughts or beliefs are the only ones that matter. While I respect your right to your opinion, your finger pointing throughout your column offers little that is constructive. And that is unfortunate. My relatives faught so people like yourself could come here and freely share your views. Yet in your column you purport things like the subheadline "Why do they hate us." Then you talk about our government's propaganda at the same time? America doesn't hate you. We just dont like that you only choose to pick and choose the most negative things you can find in your column about our great country, when you had the platform to do much more with your words. Something to think about. Without America, we would all be speaking German or Japanese sir.
Janet P September 12, 2011 at 03:46 AM
I also find it deeply disturbing that your religion is one that restricts what women can and cannot wear based on your beliefs. Something else to think about the next time you question why people have had feelings of resentment, sir, even if they are misguided or wrong. Thanks for sharing your opinions though. America is inclusive, and lest we forget, Glenview was once home to one of the country's greatest Navy bases full of wonderful people for a long, long time.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »